Thursday, November 11, 2010

British Soldiers Burn In Hell...

A relative of mine just posted this as her facebook status:

Today muslims broke the 2minutes silence in Central London with holding banners "British Soldiers Burn In Hell" & with the burning of a poppy... KICK ALL THE DISRESPECTFUL BASTARDS OUT OF THIS COUNTRY!!!! copy and paste this if you agree


This is my response:

I don't agree with the banners at all- to say that about anyone who has died is disrespectful and shameful. However I can understand their reason for protesting and why they feel so strongly about the issue. This might go some way towards explaining it:

"On 11th November 2010, commonwealth countries will join together in a moment of silence to commemorate the sacrifices of their civilians and armed forces during times of war. For over a century these events have gone uninterrupted, as millions of people continue to reflect on the casualties of modern warfare.

Unfortunately, the bitter reality of Remembrance Day is that the majority of people (who participate in it) are blissfully unaware of the hidden truths behind this very distasteful event. Put simply, Remembrance Day is a symbol of imperialism and everything that is wrong with democracy and man-made law.

As Muslims, we can poignantly remember the victims of (British) military intervention, the bullets fired and the bombs dropped, the lands occupied and the resources stolen and in light of this find it very difficult to remember the perpetrators of such crimes without much anger and hostility.

The British military are currently at the forefront of some of the harshest campaigns against Islam and Muslims, and furthermore have played a crucial role in cementing economic and strategic interests that rob large Muslim populations of vital resources.

In light of this, Muslims against Crusades have organised an emergency demonstration, to highlight these injustices and to furthermore ensure that on the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month, this message is heard loudly and clearly."
From the website muslimsagainstcrusades.com.

I suppose they are so bitter and resentful because they are remembering the many women, children and men murdered by British troops in muslim countries while British people are remembering the soldiers themselves. But, of course, that certainly doesn't mean that they have a right to desecrate the memorial service. It's also important to note that it wouldn't really be possible to kick muslims out of the UK as that would be confusing muslims with immigrants and many muslims are British citizens and many British citizens are muslims and therefore have a valid and intrinsic place in our society. British soldiers who are also muslims have also died in combat in recent years. But I do totally agree that the way these people are demonstrating is very crude, provocative and aggressive. Two wrongs don't make a right and all that... They should have tried to explain and describe their point of view and educate people about why they feel this way rather than insult dead soldiers which only creates more hostility and breeds ignorance and anger. That's how I feel anyway, but I think this is too long to paste as my status... :)

2 comments:

  1. Hello!
    I am writing you because I really enjoy your blog and your post about Muslims and November 11. My name is Ricardo, I'm 34 and live in Sao Joao Da Madeira, about 40 km from Porto. I almost every Saturday and sometimes even on Sundays I go there.
    Now speaking a little more serious, I lived 16 years in Montreal (Canada) and one and a half in the city of Burlington in Vermont (USA) and I'm in Portugal for 13 years. So I speak good Portuguese, French and English. During the 16 years I lived in Montreal, despite having a large Muslim community in many countries, there has never been big problems. For what I know now it all began with the attacks of September 11. Since that day, I could never see these people, I hate that race, then there was March 11 in Madrid and the July 4 in London. Lately, there has been a threat all over the world, until the 1st French lady, Carla Bruni. For these and other reasons I can not stand these people.
    I love my country and yours, but what I miss is the people who live in Porto and who to discuss issues and exchange ideas in English, are not always easy to find, but there is, in some public places in big city like Porto.
    I love cinema, rock, traveling, electronica, go to a bar with friends and soccer (FC Porto).
    Continue the excellent work and have great ideas and a long future for your blog.
    Until a next

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Ricardo- Thanks for your comment.

    I understand that many people in the West began to feel animosity and distrust towards Muslims after September 11th but I really think that it is ignorant to say that you hate/dislike/don't trust 1.57 billion people you've never met because of what a small group of people have done! I think stereotyping and discrimination occur in all cultures but we need to seek out the truth about Islam and Muslim culture and to educate ourselves rather than making generalisations; I truly believe that the majority of Muslims are peaceful, honest good people. Unfortunately a small majority with extreme views have distorted perceptions and bred hatred and intolerance. Look at it a different way- not everyone in Great Britain thinks that everyone in Ireland is violent, aggressive and a terrorist simply because the IRA bombed the British mainland and killed people for many years so we shouldn't paint all Muslims with the same brush and blame them all for the actions of a small minority.

    ReplyDelete